3 Stars Out of 5: The Idea of Scrambled Eggs in Chapli Kabab Makes Me Want to Scream!
Aadab from Northern California (USA). I am a personal chef (home cook) focusing on learning and exploring regional cuisines from present-day India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Iran.
I am experienced in using specialty spices and herbs, e.g. vetiver roots (Chrysopogon zizanioides, syn. Vetiveria zizanioides), lesser galangal (Alpinia officinarum), culinary-grade white sandalwood (Santalum album), and spiked ginger lily (Hedychium spicatum)—in the blending and layering of spices from Dastarkhwan-e-Awadh and Hyderabadi Ghizaayat.
The heirloom recipes of Mussharaf-ul-Nissa Begum ji of Chandausi, Uttar Pradesh, are collected and curated by her granddaughter and author, Pernia Qureshi, of the affluent Qureshi family. While the collected recipes are fascinating and enjoyable to cook, these are not purist Rampuri recipes sourced from archival cookbooks in Persian and Urdu preserved from Rampur's Raza Library.
My initial issue with the book is its reliance on store-bought spice brands. Despite an opening chapter dedicated to "Spices and Basic Recipes," including in-house family recipes for garam masala, chaat masala, biryani masala, nihari mixed masale, and haleem masala—some of the recipes default to commercial blends. For example, the "Veg Seekh Kabab" (p. 29) calls for Kitchen King® masala, and the "Lahori Seekh Kabab" (p. 36) requires Green Label® Madras curry powder. For a work highlighting heirloom heritage, outsourcing these fundamental flavor profiles to mass-market brands is a disappointing shortcut.
The most egregious failure is the "Mutton Biryani" recipe on page 143, which calls for a staggering 200 g of biryani masala per 1 kg of mutton. To be clear: 200 g biryani masala equates to roughly 1¾ cups of biryani masala. Attempting this ratio would result in an abrasive, horrendously bitter, and utterly inedible waste of food!
I have since received personal confirmation from Shrimati Priya Kapoor ji, Director of Roli Books, admitting the error for the book's errata:
"Thank you for pointing this out—you are absolutely right. The correct quantity is 65 grams of biryani masala for one kilogram of mutton for the 'Mutton Biryani' recipe. Our apologies for any inconvenience caused, and once again, thank you for taking the time to bring this to our attention."
Despite the errors, I still recommend Ammi's Kitchen: Heirloom Recipes from Rampur.
However, if you wish to explore purist Rampur recipes sourced and translated from Persian and Urdu at the Rampur Raza Library, consider the following works from a Rampuri-native culinary custodian, steward, and historian: Degh to Dastarkhwan: Qissas and Recipes from Rampur Cuisine and The Rampur Cookbook. The latter book is scheduled to be published August 18, 2026 in India via Bloomsbury India.
Ronald N. Tan
Personal Chef at Tan Can Cook
Vacaville, California (US)
Personal Chef at Tan Can Cook
Vacaville, California (US)